Will your vessel performance figure survive a charterer's claim?

November 18, 2026
TL;DR: When a charterer disputes a vessel's speed and consumption, the argument is rarely about whether the ship underperformed. It is about whether your figure was derived in a way the other side can pull apart. Vessel performance monitoring earns its keep at that moment, and ZeroNorth's AI-enabled fuel model is DNV-verified at 93.8% accuracy, which is what allows a consumption figure to stand without being re-derived by the counterparty.

A claim arrives against a vessel on time charter. The charterer's calculation shows the ship burned more than warranted and arrived later than instructed. Your own figures show something different.

Nobody is lying. Both sides have measured the same voyage in defensible ways, and the gap between them is worth real money.

Performance claims are rarely settled on how the vessel actually performed. They are settled on how each side derived its number: which hours were counted, which speed reference was used, and which engines were included. A vessel performance monitoring system is worth what it can defend, not what it can collect.

What a charterer actually disputes

A counterparty rarely disputes that the vessel sailed; they dispute the derivation behind your figure.

The challenge lands in one of three places. Which periods of the voyage count toward the warranty, since conditions outside agreed limits are normally excluded. Which speed the charter party warrants, since a figure measured one way will not match a figure measured the other. And which consumption belongs to the warranty at all, since main engine and auxiliary burn are often warranted separately, or not at all.

Each of those is a question about method. If a system cannot show its working on all three, the claim gets argued on the counterparty's terms.

What vessel performance monitoring has to produce

Vessel performance monitoring has to produce a figure with its derivation attached, not a dashboard number.

That means the voyage is segmented before it is assessed. Periods are classified against the charter party's own weather and operating conditions, speed is stated against an explicit reference, and consumption is attributed to the machinery that burned it. What a claims discussion needs is a single report setting instructed against actual against warranted, with excluded periods visible rather than averaged away.

ZeroNorth vessel performance monitoring is built for that moment. SMARTShip reconciles reported and sensed data, holds charter party conditions per vessel, and issues end-of-voyage reporting that places the instructed figure beside the actual result and the good weather result. ZeroNorth also runs a claims desk that sends those reports to operators and chartering teams as voyages close, which is a different proposition from a platform that displays a number and leaves the defence to you. Where reported and sensed figures disagree, the reconciliation question is covered separately in which data source to trust.

The three places a claim is won or lost

Three method questions decide most performance claims, and all three are settled before any number is compared.

Speed through the water, or speed over the ground. Speed over ground includes the current; speed through water does not. A ship making 11.5 knots through the water in half a knot of favourable current is making 12 over the ground. Both are honest numbers and they support opposite conclusions. Charter parties normally warrant one of them explicitly. A system that reports a single reference, or does not state which reference it is reporting, hands the counterparty an easy objection.

Good weather periods. Speed and consumption warranties usually apply only within agreed condition limits, so the first task in a claim is deciding which hours qualify. This is where voyage averages mislead: a vessel can miss its warranted figure across a full passage and meet it comfortably across the good weather hours, or the reverse. Those hours have to be isolated on observed conditions, with the exclusions visible to both sides.

Main engine and auxiliary engine. Total daily consumption is not a warranty. Charter parties commonly warrant main engine burn at a given speed and treat auxiliary consumption separately, so a merged figure cannot be assessed against either. Splitting them is not a reporting nicety; it decides whether a claim can be evaluated at all.

Which approach survives a claim

Choose an approach by what it lets you put in front of a counterparty, not by how much data it gathers.

ApproachWhat it answers wellWhere it fails in a claimWhat you can put in front of a counterparty
Voyage averages from reported dataFleet-level trends and basic compliance reportingBlends qualifying and excluded hours into a single number, and cannot show which periods were assessedInternal review only; little that withstands the other side's own calculation
Continuous sensor data, unsegmentedFault detection and high-frequency technical diagnosticsVolume without a warranty reference: no speed basis stated, no good weather isolation, no split by machineryA technical argument about the vessel, not a position on the warranty
Voyage segmented against charter party conditions, on a third-party verified modelAssessing actual performance against the specific warranty that appliesRequires charter party conditions maintained per vessel, and more work at onboardingInstructed against actual against good weather, with exclusions and speed basis stated, on a model the other side cannot simply re-derive

What independent verification changes

Independent verification is what stops a consumption figure being re-derived by the other side.

A counterparty can set aside a vendor's internal benchmark without much effort. A model verified by an accredited third party is harder to wave away, because the accuracy claim does not rest on the party making it. ZeroNorth's fuel and emissions reporting runs through accredited third-party verification with DNV, described in verified fuel reporting, and ZeroNorth's AI-enabled fuel model is verified at 93.8% accuracy.

That matters most wherever a figure leaves your organisation: a charter party discussion, an emissions statement passed to a charterer, or an invoice that has to survive scrutiny. The wider case for measuring what monitoring returns is set out in proving the value of performance monitoring.

The bottom line

Put the vendor-neutral question first: when a charterer challenges this number, what exactly do you hand them?

Four specifics decide the answer. Does the system state which speed reference it reports against, and can it report both? Can it isolate good weather periods on observed conditions and show the excluded hours? Does it separate main engine from auxiliary consumption so each is assessed against the warranty that applies? And is the fuel model verified outside your own organisation, so the figure is not simply re-derived by the counterparty?

If those are the questions on your desk, see how SMARTShip handles them, review pricing, or book a demo and bring a disputed voyage to the call.

FAQ

In case you missed anything

Explore a curated collection of guides, tools, and insights designed to help you get the most out of our products and services.
What does a charterer need before they will accept a vessel performance figure?
A derivation they can follow. That means the speed reference stated explicitly, the good weather hours isolated on observed conditions with exclusions shown, main engine and auxiliary consumption separated, and a fuel model verified by a third party rather than benchmarked internally by the vendor supplying the figure.
Is charter party speed measured through the water or over the ground?
It depends on the charter party, which is why the reference has to be stated. Speed over ground includes the current; speed through water removes it. The same passage yields different figures under each, so a system reporting only one reference, or not naming it, invites a challenge.
What counts as a good weather period in a performance claim?
The hours falling within the condition limits the charter party sets, typically defined by wind force and sea state. Only those hours are normally assessed against the warranty. Voyage averages mislead because they blend qualifying and excluded hours, so the qualifying periods must be isolated and the exclusions made visible.
Should main engine and auxiliary engine consumption be assessed separately?
Yes. Charter parties commonly warrant main engine consumption at a given speed and treat auxiliary burn separately, or leave it unwarranted. A single total daily figure cannot be assessed against either warranty, so a system that does not split consumption by machinery leaves the claim unevaluable.
How do we know the fuel consumption model is accurate?
Look for verification from outside the vendor. ZeroNorth's AI-enabled fuel model has been verified by DNV at 93.8% accuracy, which is what allows the resulting figures to be used in charter party and emissions conversations without the counterparty re-deriving them from their own assumptions.

Engineering the future of sustainable trade, technology to help shipping operate at its full potential.

Follow us